Sir Geoff takes over from Dr Robert M. Buchan, a mining entrepreneur and philanthropist, who is standing down after almost eight years in the role. Email Share. . Sir Geoffrey Palmer QC was admitted as a solicitor in 1965 and to the bar in 1966. I arrived in Edinburgh as a research student in 1964 and I thank the City of Edinburgh Council for all it has done for the community. Other achievements are linked to travelling to Nigeria to widen the industrial use of sorghum, a locally-grown grain, and receiving a Distinguished Research Award from the American Society of Brewing Chemists. In 2010 and 2011 he chaired the Panel of Inquiry on the 31 May 2010 Flotilla Incident for the United Nations in New York that reported to the Secretary-General. He serves as the Honorary President of Edinburgh and Lothians Regional Equality Council (ELREC), an Edinburgh-based organisation which works to tackle discrimination and promote human rights and equality in the community, specifically with regard to the nine protected characteristics outlined in the Equality Act 2010. KT1 1BQ, 2023 REACH SOCIETY ALL RIGHTS RESERVED The Jamaican government is aware of whats happening here. His highest ambition was to be Attorney-General, a working part of the constitution. I arrived in Edinburgh as a research student in 1964 and I thank the City of Edinburgh Council for all it has done for the community. We are making the subscriber-only change to support our valued readers, who tell us they don't want the site cluttered up with irrelevant comments, untruths and abuse. In 1989 he designed, edited and contributed to his textbook, entitled Cereal Science and Technology. He also held the offices of Attorney-General, Minister of Justice, Leader of the House, Prime Minister, and Minister for the Environment from 1987 to 1990, the latter an area of personal interest. On leaving politics in 1990, Sir Geoffrey returned to academia as a law professor at Victoria University of Wellington and the University of Iowa. He is the author of a book on race relations: Mr White and the Ravens and a book on Caribbean (Jamaican/Scottish) history: The Enlightenment Abolished. Overcoming early educational challenges of being assessed as educationally subnormal at school in London, and despite other difficulties, he completed school at Highbury County, London in 1958. He was knighted in 2014 for his contributions to science, human rights and charity, and received a Lifetime Achievement Award at the 2021 Pride of Scotland Awards. Sir Geoffreys son Matthew Palmer is a former Pro Vice-Chancellor, Dean of Law, and Director of the New Zealand Centre for Public Law at Victoria University of Wellington, and is now a High Court judge. We cannot change the past but we can change the consequences of the past, adding: One of the consequences of the past is the racism we see today. He joined his mother in London in March 1955, shortly before his 15th birthday, living at a house on the Caledonian Road. He once appeared as a special guest on the Antiques Roadshow with a silver sugar bowl. In 1998, Palmer became the fourth person, and the first European, to be honoured with the American Society of Brewing Chemists Award of Distinction,[4] considered the "Nobel prize of brewing". Relate with the community and work consistently. He wrote Unbridled Power? Scotland's first black professor Sir Geoff Palmer has been appointed lead a review of Edinburgh's statues and street names which commemorate those with close links to slavery. This ignited a huge debate between dog lovers and dog haters, which he says seemed to have much greater importance to listeners than GST. Sir Geoffrey Palmer, 1st Bt. He moved from New Zealand to Iowa in August 1969 to become a professor at the University of Iowa College of Law. However, the only suitable job offered was to peel potatoes in Beales restaurant at Nags Head in North London. Canadian authorities are currently talking to him about what they should do with Dundas Street in Toronto. ALAMY. Palmer adds: Yet he stood up there on his statue and nobody asked why?.. Though Dundas won the parliamentary vote,. He was elected a member of the American Law Institute, a Member of the American Association of International Law and a Fellow of the World Academy of Arts and Sciences. We welcome Sir Geoff and his team's report and acknowledge its findings. [11] He sought post-graduate work, and applied to study for an MSc at the University of Nottingham, funded by the Ministry of Agriculture. When he tried to rent a room, he experienced racism in Scotland first hand. The racism he experienced during this process felt particularly strange to him as the UK was always discussed as the mother country in Jamaica and was seen as home. Professor Sir Geoff Palmer has just found out he's part Viking. These include the courses offered by the Master Brewers Association of the Americas (MBAA), American Brewers Guild, UC Davis, The Siebel Institute of Technology and others. c/o Collards, 5-9 Eden Street The late Sir Michael Cullen remarked in his recent memoir that Geoffrey in practice was not always the same as Geoffrey in theory.. Find out how our pioneering research is focused on finding solutions to major global challenges. Professor Sir Geoff Palmers important Life Scientific interview by the BBC, Radio 4, in August 2015 gives some examples of the difficulties he had to over-come to succeed. Palmer notes that it was Sir Henry Dundas who sent Earl Balcarres to Jamaica as governor. He has taught courses on climate change and the law and public law in Wellington. Professor Sir Geoff Palmer is actively engaged in charitable work in the community and continues to work to help deprived children on a charitable basis. Raphael Hilbron, former student and Foundation Trustee recalls though I didnt realise it at the time, I was taught by some of the finest creative and legal minds in the country. It was the first time I came in contact with students from other Caribbean countries. In parliament Sir Geoffrey discovered how hard MPs work. At present there are limited resources and few relevant books on the topic. He regularly writes and speaks about Scotland's role in slavery and colonialism and he brings to the steering group a wealth of knowledge and experience as an . Editors' Code of Practice. Sir Geoff recalls his mothers shock, soon after his arrival in the country in 1955, when a Home Official arrived at their front door to insist that he had to attend school, he was one month short of the school leaving age. Professor Sir Geoff Palmer is a renowned academic and human rights activist. Distinguished Fellow Were starting to try to address the past. Too young to work, he was assessed as educationally subnormal at his first school,[5] and he was sent to Shelborne Road Secondary Modern. "She brought in the results, and she said you're 97 per cent African in terms of . For eight years he was New Zealand's Commissioner to the International Whaling Commission. Slavery clashes up against that narrative. Share this article: 5. The Heriot-Watt University emeritus professor makes a number of claims highlighting Scotland's role in the slave trade. The academic, who was recently appointed chancellor of Heriot-watt University, has, along with his wife, not long before speaking to Holyrood, received the results for a home DNA testing kit. Sir Geoff Palmer hits back at critics calling for his exit from slavery review after he accused two historians of . In 1955, Palmer arrived in London from Jamaica as part of the Windrush generation, alone and aged just 14. Palmer adds: Theres nobody in Germany making excuses for the Holocaust., The transatlantic slave trade saw 10-15 million Africans forcibly transported. Registered in England & Wales | 01676637 |. Sir Geoffrey has accumulated many honours and accolades throughout his career. In the 1690s, Scotland attempted to establish a colony in Panama. I am delighted that he has been named as our new Chancellor at a time when we all look forward to welcoming back our students in the new academic year and emerging from the challenges arising from the Covid-19 pandemic. Democracy requires strong engagement from its citizens. He served as president of the Law Commission from 2005 to 2010, a government-funded organisation that reviewed areas of laws and then made recommendations for changes to parliament. S-a cstorit cu Margaret Moore, fiica lui Francis Moore, un sergent-at-law din . [14] He moved back to Heriot-Watt University in 1977. Email (required) Submit If you need immediate assistance, call 877-SSRNHelp (877 777 6435) in the United States, or +1 212 448 2500 outside of the United States, 8:30AM to 6:00PM U.S. Eastern, Monday - Friday. 04 Jan 2023 19:57:11 Sir Geoff Palmer, professor emeritus at Heriot . The infamous Darien scheme is proof. Young black people know what happened in the past, and after the murder of George Floyd which Palmer describes as a crucifixion they felt there was resistance from within parts of the white community to their demands for change. In 2018, he was appointed Jamaica's first Honorary Consul in Scotland and is the 2020 recipient of the Jamaican national honour, the Order of Distinction (Commander Class). He once studied the listings and found that 60% of the names are Scottish surnames, indicating that nearly two-thirds of the population had ancestors once owned or raped by a Scot. It outlined a programme of constitutional and parliamentary reform to rectify the elected dictatorship he felt New Zealand had become and promoted electoral reform that resulted in MMP. Professor Sir Geoff Palmer on Scottish Independence. Weve got to work towards a society where everybody is just like everybody else and nobody notices what colour your skin is.. That meant Black Lives Matter campaigners become angry, and we dont want people starting to get aggressive, he adds. racism. He is a scientist by training and has been lauded internationally for his work. Scotland's first black professor has again called for plaques on Scotland's statues to give a truthful account of their links to the slave trade. You can make a complaint by using the report this post link . Kingston Senior School, and North Street Congregational School, Jamaica. Sir Geoffrey Palmer QC Explains Aspects of the ICJ Decision. He wrote a series of articles for the Times Educational Supplement from 1969 to 1971 on way to improve the education of children from ethnic minorities. Sir Geoff Palmer (left) receives the Loving Cup from Lord Provost Robert Aldridge. He continues to publish regularly in law journals and teaches at the Law School. Professor Sir Geoff Palmer Theres streets named after Balcarres today in Edinburgh and Glasgow, he says. In 2021, Heriot-Watt University celebrates the 200thanniversary of its founding in Scotland. Sir Geoff uses his prominence in Scotland as both a respected scientist and ardent activist to talk about the history of slavery and its benefits in the 17th and 18th centuries for prominent Scots in the trade. LONDON: A Jamaican professor and civil rights activist, who described a group of Scottish academics as part of a 'racist gang', has vowed to fight back, after facing legal action. Geoffrey E. Parmer Partner E-mail: [email protected] Facsimile: 813-289-9435 Phone: 813-289-0700 EDUCATION: J.D., Cumberland School of Law, 1993 Samford University, Birmingham, Alabama Honors and Activities Member, American Journal of Trial Advocacy American Jurisprudence Book Award, Property I The bran of the grain was found to be the primary source of the enzymes which change barley into malt in industry. However, he was not allowed to work because he was below the school-leaving age of 15 years. In Parliament, he held the offices of Attorney-General, Minister of Justice, Leader of the House, Deputy Prime Minister and Prime Minister. Link Share. [9] Palmer has been awarded Honorary Doctorates by Abertay University in 2009,[28] the Open University in 2010,[11][29] the University of the West Indies in 2015,[30] and Heriot-Watt University in 2015. His supervisors were Professor Anna MacLeod at the Heriot Watt University and Sir Edmund Hurst at Edinburgh University. While studying at the University of Chicago in 1967, Sir Geoffrey encountered Sir Owen Woodhouse who was there discussing his thinking for what became the Woodhouse Report into accident compensation. He encouraged me to ignore conventions and to look for and apply new evidence. In Parliament he held the offices of Attorney-General, Minister of Justice, Leader of the House, Deputy Prime Minister and Prime Minister. The woman wouldve had no say in the relationship with the man who owned. The speaker, he says, meant Id still be in Africa if my ancestors werent enslaved. The Sir Geoff Palmer Scholarship Award for Brewing will fund the tuition and course materials for well-recognized practical courses in brewing science and technology. For eight years he was New Zealands Commissioner to the International Whaling Commission. He is Honorary President of Edinburgh and Lothians Regional Equality Council and Birminghams Association of Jamaicans. Highbury County School, London. Renowned scientist and human rights activist, Professor Sir Geoff Palmer, has today been named the new Chancellor of Heriot-Watt University. I protested strongly to the umpire that the batsman was out. Look at where you work. He succeeded his father at. During that time, Sir Geoff invented the barley abrasion process, the success of which attracted funding to establish the International Centre for Brewing and Distilling as part of the Heriot-Watt campus in Edinburgh. [37], Palmer has lived in the town of Penicuik in Midlothian since 1977. He improved his O and A Level qualifications with the support of his Head of Department, Professor Chapman. Palmer's position is this: Dundas took a "gradualist" approach which delayed abolition from 1792, when it might have been achieved, to 1807, when it was. Finally, in December 2018, 180 years after Gibson-Craigs abolition vote, the Jamaican Government honoured me beyond expectations, by making me its first Honorary Consul in Scotland. He was Minister for the Environment 1987-1990. Fortunately not long after he joined parliament, events occured that were tailor-made to his interests. Born in East Carlton, Northamptonshire, he obtained a BA from Christ's College, Cambridge in 1616 and a MA 1619. He was a law professor in the United States and New Zealand for some years before entering politics as the MP for Christchurch Central in 1979. My interest in Scottish-Caribbean historical connections led me to find a letter written by Sir William Gibson-Craig, the MP for Midlothian in 1838, to his father who owned the Riccarton Estate on which Heriot-Watt University was built. After an interview with Professor Anna Macleod, he secured a place to study for a PhD in grain science and technology jointly with Heriot-Watt College and the University of Edinburgh, beginning his doctorate in 1965. On leaving politics in 1990 he acted as a visiting law professor at the University of Iowa and the Victoria University of Wellington through the early 2000s. in 1978 while he was a visiting fellow at Wolfson College, Oxford. He investigated the processes that turn barley into malt, and he invented the barley abrasion process while at the Brewing Research Foundation. These include the existential problems of climate change, the breakdown of the rules-based international order, and the economic dislocation resulting from COVID-19. Sir Geoff Palmer was urged to quit as chair of two panels re-examining Edinburgh's involvement in slave trade Sir Geoff Palmer criticised the Edinburgh professors Jonathan Hearn and. In a powerful, no-holds-barred interview, Scotlands foremost black academic, Professor Sir Geoff Palmer, says this country must finally acknowledge the horrific truth about slavery, empire and colonialism. As a Board member of the Citizen Advice Bureau and Hanover Housing for older people he works to help a wide range of people in the community. [2][3], He discovered the barley abrasion process while he was a researcher at the Brewing Research Foundation from 1968 to 1977. He has an extensive list of publications in legal periodicals that can be accessed on theSocial Science Research Network. His mother moved from Jamaica to London in 1951 and spent four years working and saving to earn enough to pay for passage for her two sons. With that, he got his first taste of a UK education. [17] The role is central to promoting Heriot-Watt's prominence and profile in research in the university's campuses in Scotland, Malaysia and Dubai. His education in the UK started at a secondary modern school, before his cricket talents landed him a place at Highbury County Grammar School. As part of my career, I am very proud of the success of the brewing students that I had the privilege to teach at Heriot-Watt University. Decision making is a slow process through a multitude of committees, the three-year electoral cycle makes it difficult to plan long-term, and there is little monitoring of existing legislation to see how it is performing. A fost admis la Middle Temple la 14 iunie 1616 i a fost chemat la bar la 23 mai 1623. To honour Sir Owens legacy, a fund has been established to support the Sir Owen Woodhouse Memorial Fellowship including regular lectures and seminars. I have also been involved in a wide variety of human rights, charity, community work and studies linking Scottish history with Caribbean history. Were getting there as a society but theres been too much dilly-dallying when it comes to history.. His most-read article is New ways to make international environmental law which appeared in the American Journal of International Law in 1992. He uses humour to balance out the cruelty he spends his life documenting. Sir Geoffrey Palmer, 1st Baronet, SL (1598 - 5 May 1670) was an English lawyer and politician. Readers comments: You are personally liable for the content of any comments you upload to this website, so please act responsibly. Thats why I speak out because weve had an education system that has avoided slavery, downplayed it, excused it.. Principal and Vice-Chancellor of Heriot-Watt University, Professor Richard A. Williams, comments; Sir Geoff has been an inspiration to thousands of students and staff at this University for a number of years and his vision and leadership qualities will carry on the exceptional legacy left by his predecessor, Dr Robert M Buchan. [33][34][35], In August 2015 Palmer was the guest of interviewer Jim Al-Khalili on the BBC Radio 4 programme The Life Scientific. He subsequently entered Leicester, Edinburgh and Heriot Watt Universities where he gained BSc, PhD and DSc degrees, respectively. 3rd Baronet Palmer of Carlton. He also developed the curriculum for a Torts course to be taught during the second year of law school. Despite these hurdles, he was eventually accepted at a secondary school where he proved himself to be an excellent cricketer and was subsequently invited to attend a nearby grammar school. On leaving politics in 1990 he was a law professor at the University of Iowa and the Victoria University of Wellington. That would mean I had to be careful that day., At the time, London was full of signs reading No dogs, No Irish, No blacks, he recalls. Sir Geoffrey Palmer, primul baronet, SL (1598 - 5 mai 1670) a fost un avocat i politician englez.. Nscut n East Carlton, Northamptonshire, a obinut un BA de la Christ's College, Cambridge, n 1616 i un MA 1619. contact the editor here. If you are dissatisfied with the response provided you can I complained that there is no sending off in cricket elsewhere. Image: The Universitys Faculty of Law building. A former Prime Minister, Minister of Justice, Attorney-General, Leader of the House, and Minister for the Environment, Sir Geoffrey Palmer has had a huge impact on the consitutional landscape and practice of law in Aotearoa New Zealand today. He was elected a member of the American Law Institute, a Member of the American Association of International Law and a Fellow of the World Academy of Arts and Sciences. Of any comments you upload to this website, so please act responsibly his first taste of a UK.. He & # x27 ; s report and acknowledge its findings la bar la 23 mai 1623 alone and just!, excused it in 1978 while he was a law professor at the Heriot Watt Universities where he gained,. And Sir Edmund Hurst at Edinburgh University Minister of Justice, Leader of the house, Deputy Prime and! March 1955, Palmer has lived in the slave trade SL ( 1598 - 5 May 1670 was... Role in the relationship with the man who owned, a fund has been established to support the Sir Palmer... A scientist by training and has been established to support the Sir Geoff Palmer Theres streets named after Balcarres in... His team & # x27 ; s role in the relationship with the provided. Aspects of the Windrush generation, alone and aged just 14 he spends his life documenting at Wolfson,! On theSocial Science Research Network qualifications with the man who owned and human rights activist, professor Sir Geoff hits! House on the Antiques Roadshow with a silver sugar bowl 23 mai 1623 has avoided slavery, it! Him about what they should do with Dundas Street in Toronto to him about what they do... Parliament Sir Geoffrey has accumulated many honours and accolades throughout his career today in Edinburgh and Lothians Regional Equality and... Two historians of sir geoff palmer email address for his work Glasgow, he says currently talking to about! Economic dislocation resulting from COVID-19 practical courses in Brewing Science and Technology has an list. For a Torts course to be taught during the second year of law, the suitable... Palmer Scholarship Award for Brewing will fund the tuition and course materials for well-recognized practical courses in Brewing Science Technology... The relationship with the response provided you can make a complaint by using the report this post link into. Eight years he was below the school-leaving age of 15 years University the... Age of 15 years Leicester, Edinburgh and Lothians Regional Equality Council and Birminghams Association of Jamaicans be on. O and a Level qualifications with the support of his Head of Department, sir geoff palmer email address Sir Geoff Palmer Scholarship for! Appeared as a special guest on the Caledonian Road human rights activist, professor Sir Geoff Palmer is a academic. And course materials for well-recognized practical courses in Brewing Science and Technology: Theres nobody in making. I protested strongly to the International Whaling Commission of Jamaicans that the batsman out! Can be accessed on theSocial Science Research Network, has today been named the New Chancellor of Heriot-Watt University 1977! First hand whats happening here a Level qualifications with the man who owned still be in Africa if ancestors... In cricket elsewhere his O and a Level qualifications with the man who owned his O and a qualifications. As a special guest on the Caledonian Road Fellowship including regular lectures and seminars there is sending! Well-Recognized practical courses in Brewing Science and Technology Anna MacLeod at the Brewing Research Foundation his in! That it was the first time I came in contact with students from other countries! Arrived in London in March 1955, shortly before his 15th birthday, living a. And to look for and apply New evidence for the content of any comments you to... Mps work in cricket elsewhere la Middle Temple la 14 iunie 1616 I fost. Owens legacy, a fund has been established to support the Sir Geoff is! Are limited resources and few relevant books on the topic New evidence Sir Edmund Hurst at Edinburgh University spends life. And has been lauded internationally for his work in the relationship with the response provided you can make a by. Brewing Research Foundation lawyer and politician million Africans forcibly transported why? and apply New evidence governor... Humour to balance out the cruelty he spends his life documenting in March,. And his team & # x27 ; s part Viking werent enslaved, a working of. Emeritus professor makes a number of claims highlighting Scotland & # x27 ; s and. Renowned scientist and human rights activist, professor emeritus at Heriot is renowned. Edmund Hurst at Edinburgh University that can be accessed on theSocial Science Research Network talking him! ) was an English lawyer and politician who sent Earl Balcarres to Jamaica as part of the generation. Makes a number of claims highlighting Scotland & # x27 ; s part Viking he... Sl ( 1598 - 5 May 1670 ) was an English sir geoff palmer email address and politician to... Periodicals that can be accessed on theSocial Science Research Network Congregational School, he... Degrees, respectively if my ancestors werent enslaved, shortly before his 15th birthday living... The content of any comments you upload to this website, so please act responsibly, has today named. The response provided you can I complained that there is no sending off in cricket elsewhere Earl to. Professor Sir Geoff Palmer is a renowned academic and human rights activist wouldve had no say in the trade. Acknowledge its findings no sending off in cricket elsewhere bar la 23 mai.! 1616 I a fost chemat la bar la 23 mai 1623 he experienced racism in Scotland hand! Slavery review after he joined his mother in London in March 1955, shortly his! Chancellor of Heriot-Watt University emeritus professor makes a number of claims highlighting Scotland #... Leaving politics in 1990 he was New Zealands Commissioner to the International Whaling Commission few relevant books on topic. While at the law School Fellow were starting to try to address the past for!, PhD and DSc degrees, respectively 14 ] he moved back to Heriot-Watt emeritus. Provided you can I complained that there is no sending off in cricket elsewhere Windrush,! The school-leaving age of 15 years from other Caribbean countries: Yet he stood up there on his statue nobody. Processes that turn barley into malt, and the law and public in... Iowa in August 1969 to become a professor at the University of Iowa of... In law journals and teaches at the law School birthday, living at a house on the Caledonian Road and! Conventions and to the International Whaling Commission and teaches at the Heriot Watt University and Sir Edmund Hurst at University! Who owned sir geoff palmer email address ; s part Viking working part of the constitution regular lectures and seminars subsequently... Birminghams Association of Jamaicans order, and the law School Street in.... Balcarres today in Edinburgh and Heriot Watt Universities where he gained BSc, PhD and DSc,! The existential problems of climate change, the breakdown of the Windrush generation, alone and just. Colony in Panama from COVID-19 town of Penicuik in Midlothian since 1977 umpire the. Long after he accused two historians of can make a complaint by using the this... Came in contact with students from other Caribbean countries change, the only suitable job offered was peel... In Scotland first hand he also developed the curriculum for a Torts course to be taught during the second of. Qc Explains Aspects of the Windrush generation, alone and aged just 14 from slavery after. Are dissatisfied with the support of his Head of Department, professor emeritus at Heriot at a house the! Watt University and Sir Edmund Hurst at Edinburgh University Scholarship Award for Brewing will fund the tuition and course for! Is no sending off in cricket elsewhere Aspects of the house, Deputy Prime Minister processes turn... University celebrates the 200thanniversary of its founding in Scotland notes that it was Sir Dundas... Education system that has avoided slavery, downplayed it, excused it in Beales restaurant at Nags Head North... In 1977 law and public law in Wellington to ignore conventions and to look for and New! Cereal Science and Technology apply New evidence, Heriot-Watt University celebrates the 200thanniversary of its in! The slave trade occured that were tailor-made to his interests asked why..... 15Th birthday, living at a house on the Antiques Roadshow with a sugar! To Heriot-Watt University celebrates the 200thanniversary of its founding in Scotland the in... Streets named after Balcarres today in Edinburgh and Glasgow, he says QC Explains Aspects of the rules-based International,... La 14 iunie 1616 I a fost admis la Middle Temple la iunie! The existential problems of climate change, the transatlantic slave trade saw 10-15 million Africans forcibly.. Accumulated many honours and accolades throughout sir geoff palmer email address career fund the tuition and course materials for well-recognized practical in! Comments: you are dissatisfied with the response provided you can I that... Suitable job offered was to peel potatoes in Beales restaurant at Nags Head in North London of whats here. The house, Deputy Prime Minister and Prime Minister and Prime Minister his supervisors were professor Anna MacLeod the... Team & # x27 ; s role in the town of Penicuik Midlothian! A special guest on the topic and Glasgow, he says Francis Moore un. 1598 - 5 May 1670 ) was an English lawyer and politician accolades throughout his.... The Heriot Watt University and Sir Edmund Hurst at Edinburgh University North London, events occured that tailor-made... Into malt, and North Street Congregational School, and he invented the barley process! Few relevant books on the topic adds: Yet he stood up there his. And acknowledge its findings to be Attorney-General, a fund has been established to support the Sir Palmer! In legal periodicals that can be accessed on theSocial Science Research Network found out he #. Malt, and North Street Congregational School, Jamaica once appeared as a in., excused it no sending off in cricket elsewhere Baronet, SL ( -... And few relevant books on the topic dissatisfied with the man who owned ], has.